Buffalo chicken sandwich was delish. If you get a bagel w cc make sure you ask to get it toasted. Friendly group of guys at the register!

The best everything bagel I ever had was from this place. Perfectly coated with all the seasonings. Toasted with a fried egg inside is delicious. The coffee is always fresh. Definitely one of the better bagel shops in the area. Check them out

Their food is phenomenal Their prices are great & they have great customer services (Fast, Professional & Friendly)

Bagel Supreme has been my go-to for breakfast and quick lunches. Every bagel, bagel sandwich, and other items I've gotten from here have been tasty. Especially if you go and order in person, there is unlimited customizability. The staff is really friendly and works to serve your order as quickly as possible. There isn't anywhere to sit down inside, but there is ample space. You can also see the day's selection of bagels and cream cheeses. They are also always stocked on drinks in their fridges, coffee, and baked goods as well. There is a good amount of parking in the back too. The only issue I've ever had with my food here has been that a quesadilla I got came out a little greasy. Other than that, everything has been a hit for me!

Absolutely top notch experience when ordering catering for a work event this week. Not only were the bagels and spreads delicious, the owner himself reached out to ensure all the details for my order were taken care of. Once the breakfast was over he reached out again to inquire how everything turned out! It's such an amazing gesture to have a business owner take the time to ensure their clients are happy. This is my new go-to spot for all of my client catering needs! 10 stars!!!

I hosted a Teacher Appreciation Luncheon yesterday for my son's school. Placed the order at their new location in Rochelle Park just because of location. Owner ( Nader) was absolutely amazing. The incredible spread of sandwiches, salad, fruit and dessert he provided was met with amazing reviews. He even made a separate platter of vegetarian options which was also amazing. Can't say enough good things. Truly a local owned family business that should be commended for his dedication to his community and his incredible catering skills. Thank you Nader and Supreme Bagels for helping make our teachers feel supported.

I enjoy their bagels. They are as good or better than all the other bagel places BUT..... They have never given me what I ordered. My mistake is leaving without checking my orders. Order a rainbow bagel (we'll stocked, I see) and you get a poppy seed. Order a dozen bagels and you get 11. Order butter and you get cream cheese. If their bagels weren't delicious, I'd give them fewer stars. 4.5 out of 5 Nader, please don't disappoint me again. A.J.

Love everything about Bagel Supreme! The owner and all of the workers have a great attitude and are all super friendly and dedicated. Yes, the prices went up (just as they did EVERY WHERE), but the high quality of all of their foods never went down. Great breakfast wraps, bagels, and sandwiches. Their fridge is always fully stocked with juices, water, Gatorade etc. And there is always fresh coffee. They also have homemade muffins that are delicious!

Finally made some time to give this place a review! Bagel Supreme is close to where I work (thank goodness!) and is a life saver for some quick bagels and sandwiches. Being in healthcare, bagels are definitely one of those quick breakfast options for me and my coworkers and this place serves some good ones. I still remember my fun treat of egg bagel with cream cheese and jelly! So delicious! They have a variety of cream cheeses too and they gave me a complimentary one during one of my visits, very much appreciated. Ive also tried some of their sandwiches, the waddy wrap and BBQ to be exact, and they were both great! Avocado was fresh and chicken meat was nicely cooked and seasoned. Im hoping to try their other sandwiches next time I stop by. I also tried their coffee but i guess im so used to getting a latte in coffee shops lately i didnt really enjoyed it when I got one here. Was too hot too, took a while to be able to drink it. I'll just stick to their bagels and sandwiches! Hehe